Yesterday my attention was been drawn to an excellent article in the Guardian about one person's attempt to return to work after having made a partial recovery from the depths of M.E. In the article, Melissa Viney sets out the difficulties of trying to move back into the working world when one has a fluctuating chronic illness like M.E.
For a long time now, people who receive Incapacity Benefit were in a sticky position if they began to think about a gradual return to work because, as Melissa says
'....IB has been a rigid, all-or-nothing system; you can work, or you can't. It takes no notice of the many chronic and fluctuating conditions .....'
From next week (October 27th) a new system, ESA (Employment and Support Allowance), will begin. This will divide claimants into those who are deemed able to do some work and a much smaller group who are deemed unable to work and are therefore excused and given a higher rate of benefit. Since the Government aims to cut the number of claimants by 20,000 p.a. you can imagine that there will be an onus on DWP Assessors (who are woefully misinformed about conditions like M.E) to take heed of the new, more stringent criteria by which people are judged to be capable of work and try to get as many people as possible in the 'able to work' category. It will remain an all or nothing system: a system which fails to address the needs of people with fluctuating conditions and which makes it almost impossible for such people to return to work with any confidence or feeling of security. If their health begins to falter and they have to give up work and have a lot of time off work, how quickly will their benefits kick in and provide a much needed safety net in terms of finance and confidence ?
Apart from clearly setting out her story and imminent changes in the benefits system, Melissa's article strikes a chord because she discusses the issue of the difference between disability and sickness. It is something I have struggled with ever since diagnosis. I have spent my life around disabled people and have always appeared to be able bodied, healthy, resilient. In fact I have been living with M.E. for over 30 years and have often felt so unwell that I have not known how to get through a working day. I have had blocks of time off work (two weeks here, one month there, three months here, three days there). I've ducked and dived my way through College, University, career because I felt there was nothing really wrong with me that a few days rest wouldn't cure --- even when a different reality was staring me in the face: it isn't normal to spend every day feeling ill and struggling to get through ordinary routines at work and home but I was always told by doctors that I was 'just unwell.'
In my last job I worked for a charity which was developed and run, in part, by disabled people: people who used wheelchairs, people who had had strokes, were deaf, blind and so on. How could I compare myself to them ? They were disabled. I just felt poorly. Some of those people would be judged unable to work by the DWP --- though they did work jolly hard. Some were paid and some worked voluntarily. Even so there was a recognition that their lives were impaired by their disability and they were supported through additional benefits, support in terms of better access to buildings and information.
I felt then, before diagnosis, and even now, that none of that kind of support or understanding was available to me. I still have the sense that I am 'just unwell 'and with that an implication that there is a possibility that I can get better, back to normal. I have the sense that, somehow, in the pecking order, I am perceived by many to be more fortunate than someone who is seen as disabled. In some ways I am.
I can walk unaided mainly.
I can hear, see, speak.
I have a normal level of understanding and intellectual ability.
But all these aspects of my self are impaired in some way and every day, every moment is a struggle.
Nobody seems to really understand that there are days when, if I can get out at all,
I too need to go up the ramp instead of the steps,
I too need noise levels reduced so I can concentrate,
I too need the understanding that I have difficulties in terms of concentration and memory,
I too need a special diet and reduced chemical levels so I don't feel dizzy, sick , confused.
I too need reduced and flexible hours because I cannot work a full day and I also need a situation where I can phone in and say,'I just can't get into work today. I don't feel up to it and if I force myself today it will have repercussions and you probably won't see me for the next week because I'll need even longer to recover.'
I'm sick of feeling apologetic and always having to explain or excuse myself.
So who has a life that is more 'unfortunate', more limited ? Who is more able, who should have more determination to get out there and contribute instead of taking advantage of State handouts ? It's certainly not a competition and there's no point in trying to determine who is worst off and who deserves a sympathy vote. In fact it's impossible and pointless to judge because any kind of impairment, illness or disability will be subject to permutation, variability and by the character of the person it inhabits. There is no black and white.
What there is, as in so many aspects of life, are many shades of grey and a desperate need for recognition of the fact that most people who receive a State Benefit because of illness or disability, do so reluctantly and with a degree of apology and embarrassment. They would dearly love to earn that money and offer something in return when they can ...and that is the point ---when they can.
However, in order for them to do so, there has to be a much deeper level of understanding of people's fallibility in the face of chronic illness, a knowledge that life with e.g. M.E. can feel very fragile and insecure and that, if there is any hope for the likes of us (PWME) returning to the working world and contributing our undoubted skills, employers and their other employees have to understand that chronic illness deserves as much respect as disability.
11 comments:
If disability is all about function, then I would guess you are disabled because you have all manner of impaired function, even if none of you impairments are absolute (e.g. no paralysis, not total blindness etc). But such 'absolutes' are rare; most disabled people have a collection of bits that don't work too well as opposed to bits that don't work at all. Only about 5% of disabled people use wheelchairs - and most of them are merely bad walkers.
If disability is about the social attitudes and practical problems we face (i.e. The Social Model) then I would guess you are disabled because some buildings, events and systems are inaccesible to you and you face prejudice. In fact, I have often said that people with mental ill health are the most disabled people in our society, because their limitations are given the very least legitimacy (and yet the most fear and suspicion).
I wrote a post on the BBC Ouch blog about ESA. I am keeping my fingers crossed, but I'm pretty confident that the rhetoric is far worse than the reality will be.
I'm glad you are hopeful and, of course I've long recognised that any sensible employer wouldn't touch the likes of me with a bargepole. I even haiver about volunteering for some things because I know how (unintentionally) unrealiable I am and, from experience at work, I know that unreliable volunteers who come in all gung ho and then don't turn up are really disappointing and make thinsg difficult to plan around.
In fact I recognise all you say. As I said, I've worked for years with disabled people (either offering services or working alongside them), my son is disabled and my partner has worked with visually impaired people for over 20 years. I know about the social model too but, for people with conditions like M.E., which is a Cinderella condition at the best of times and subject to all sorts of interpretations, diagnoses, discrepancy, treatment 'options', the notion of being assessed as being fit for work and being told things e.g 'You don't look ill' by a qualified doctor -- as described by Melissa in her article -- fills the likes of me with a kind of dread and a kind of fury.
I've already seen enough people feel like they have to go back to work at any cost when they really feel too ill (and here I'm talking about people with conditions other than M.E.) and I've seen enough of how disabled people can be treated at work: with derision, discrimination, disbelief and ill-humour. A government can pass all the laws it likes about disability but that doesn't alter ordinary people's attitudes so quickly. Here, I am talking about individuals who would usually be recognised as 'disabled': people who use wheelchairs, people who don't look like most other people, people whose speech is impaired etc. etc. If those people are discriminated against and seen as, in some way 'other', how are the likes of me to be seen ? We don't meet the commonly held expectation of how a disabled person appears and when we mention our condition, it is often met with an ill-informed prejudice and disbelief.
Having said all that I am rather thinking that the Government's best laid plans about trying to get as many people off benefits and into work will come unstuck anyway because, if we are 'in recession', as Gordon says we are, they'll be enough able-bodied, healthy people desperate for jobs without all the disabled and sick people pushing at the front of the queue.
I relate to much of what both of you are saying. In my province, they did a huge, costly review of those on disability gov't support in hopes of kicking many people off. For many months, people on disability were terrified that they would lose their monthly support. Doctors were swamped with long forms and advocates put in long hours helping people fill out endless questionnaires. I was fortunate enough to have enough on file that I didn't get reviewed, but I know people who lost many nights of sleep waiting for the decision to come down. In the end it cost the taxpayers millions of dollars and only a very small number of people lost their benefits. I can only hope that your government will end up with the same results (well, maybe not millions wasted, but few people losing their benefits).
I can also really relate to the differences in how people with disabling illness are viewed compared to those with clearly visible disabilities. There's work to be done with doctors, employers, disability organizations and our own guilt-ridden or questioning selves. I agree with Goldfish about M.E. and similar chronic illnesses fitting into both the social and functional models of disability. I look forward to reading her article. I think posts like this make me hopeful: they move the dialogue forward and open up more space for questioning and growing.
The Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) defines a disabled person as someone who has a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.
{{{{Cusp}}}}
Since my partner became disabled I have realised the level of prejudicism. Incredibly also amongst disabled people themselves.
Disability cannot be compared. Or judged.
Well my view anyway.
I identified with everything in your comment and Melissa's article. I have 'only' been off work on IB for 15 months and I have pretty much given up any expectation of going back to where I was, work wise. I am completely unable to get my head round the complexities of doing some thing useful like volunteering on the basis of 'maybe I'll be able to, but maybe not..'
As for the disabled/illness thing, I use both terms if that makes sense. I consider I am disabled by this illness. I have other chronic health conditions that don't (or didn't anyway) on their own prevent me from being active and working, so I never considered my self disabled.
Sorry, if none of that makes sense, horribly brain-fogged today
Heh Donimo and Kahless and welcome Bone Mother.
Donimo: always interesting to hear about experiences from other countries -- especially from across The Pond. As you say there's still plenty of work to be done in terms of engendering real respect and understanding of disabled and chronically ill people. For all the DDA (Disability Discrimination Act) etc., in the real world I have seen a lot of intolernace masked by a 'PC veneer.
Kahlees, thansk for your wise words.
Bone Mother: Welcome. My, you DO have a wide range of interests ;0)
I love that you've been refusing toi be good for so long. '67 was a good year for adopting new ways of being methinks. Don't worry about the fogginess. My head's a right pea-souper sometimes and waht you write makes perfect sense. Do visit again when you feel the urge.
Hi Cusp,
I never got a penny of benefit because I was not working at the time it was diagnosed (on account of having babies). I was given a couple of hours of home help a week when in Hackney but that stopped when I moved to the sticks. And I've been told that as my husband works there would be no chance at all of anything. And I got tired out trying.
Good post.
Personally I don't think the system will be able to cope with a self-imposed review of this scale, and it'll all end up being a lot of hot air and posturing. We may have a short period of uncertainty but I feel that very few people who plainly cannot work will be forced into work. I was talking about this with a couple of ME friends today and the consensus was "Who'd want us anyway?" Sad, but true as yes, it's also a lot to do with attitudes.
Would you consider mentioning my newly-published memoir on your blog? I would be happy to exchange blog feeds as well.
Seven Wheelchairs: A Life beyond Polio was recently released by The University of Iowa Press.
The memoir is a history -- an American tale -- of my fifty year wheelchair journey after being struck by both bulbar and lumbar poliomyelitis after a vaccine accident in 1959. The Press says Seven Wheelchairs gives "readers the unromantic truth about life in a wheelchair, he escapes stereotypes about people with disabilities and moves toward a place where every individual is irreplaceable."
Other reviewers have called Seven Wheelchairs "sardonic and blunt," "a compelling account," and "powerful and poetic."
I hope you can mention Seven Wheelchairs on your blog. We all live different disability stories, I know, but perhaps if you find the memoir worthwhile, you might want to recommend the book to others who are curious about what polio or disability in general.
Of course, the book is also available through Amazon and Barnes & Noble.
--
Gary Presley www.garypresley.com
SEVEN WHEELCHAIRS: A Life beyond Polio
Fall 2008 University of Iowa Press
Great post. Thanks. Thanks for directing me to the article and for your own thoughts and reflections. A lot of reasonance with me.
I see label myself sick AND disabled. I am impaired and often more impaired than traditionally labelled disabled persons. But it's by no means a competition!
I decided not to claim IB or other benefit when work stopped paying me because of not wanting to be trapped in the benefits trap. I wanted the freedom to try working for myself if i could and we could just about afford for me to not HAVE to claim benefit.
A year on I find that if I do need to claim in the future, say because my husband got sick or disabled, I wouldn't qualify because I haven't paid my NI. So for not costing the government benefit money every week my reward is to be more cut off.
Still I have the freedom to do work with a clear conscience. Not that I've been well enough to really. It can be a sh!t system.
I have a couple of friends with M.E. who have given up on the benefits system and I think it can be a real nightmare but, on the other hand, if you have worked and paid your taxes and contributions, why shouldn't you ask for some financial help. Neither of them have childrena nd also reached a point where they could work from home: one as Reiki Healer and the other as a 'maker'.
When I was first diagnosed and everything came to a shuuddering halt, we had both been working full-time and the option of opting out of the benefits system just wasn't there with two small children and a mortgage.
Sometimes I've had dreams of cocking a snook at the DWP and going it alone but I just couldn't manage to earn as much as the IB I receive and we'd be living in poverty because of my pride so it just isn't on.
If this new system does put me, or any of us, into a situation where we're forced to work (and in all honesty I doubt it will, too) it will be curtains for me because I just couldn't do it and then, no doubt, we'd have to go through the whole rigamarole of re-applying for benefits because I'd been proved right in my assertion that I'm not capable of working.
What really irks me --- and I've said it before --- is that these assessments are never made considering the whole/bigger picture i.e. it's not just about me going to work. It's about the impact my going to work would have on the whole family and all of us then trying to pull together, get ordinary things done, so I had the energy to go to work and yet still maintain a comfortable, reliable home fo rmy children.
Post a Comment